Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

Since U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement’s detention of 82 immigrants on the South Coast in September, ICE and its defenders have cited the arrests of seven of those men to call the operation a success that made Massachusetts safer.

But immigrants’ advocates say the agency’s focus on those men misrepresents the raids, which mostly detained people with no criminal records. 

In October, ICE issued a news release with the names, photos, and criminal charges of just seven of the 82 detained in southeastern Massachusetts the week of Sept. 21-23. Their charges ranged from indecent assault on minors to driving under the influence. 

Days later, former ICE Acting Director Todd Lyons cited ICE’s press release and those charges while defending the arrests in the Boston Herald.

Light staff investigated ICE’s claims about the seven men by reviewing court records in Massachusetts and Rhode Island and corroborated the claims on five of them. The Light found that two of the seven served time in the Bristol County House of Correction.

But the limited nature of ICE’s list left one advocate wondering: Why did the names released appear cherry-picked?

“It really, really misrepresents the narrative of who they’re picking up,” said Helena Dasilva Hughes, president of the Immigrants’ Assistance Center. “The reason they put out information like that is to reaffirm the narrative that President Trump has.”

Meanwhile, dozens of immigrants detained in the raids, which took place in New Bedford, Dartmouth, and Fall River, have challenged their detention in federal court. Many were released on bond in October, and in some cases, federal judges hearing their petitions acknowledged that they have no criminal records.

The allegations

Two of the men ICE named, one from Brazil and another from Portugal, faced serious charges related to indecent acts with minors.

Robson Martins Da Silva, 41, of Brazil, the first man on the ICE release, pleaded guilty to two counts of indecent assault and battery on a minor under 14 in Fall River District Court on Jan. 23. The victim was a third-grader under age 11, according to a police report filed at Fall River District Court. (A charge of possession of child sexual abuse material was dismissed.) 

The judge imposed a sentence of 2½ years in prison and ordered Da Silva to serve one year in the Bristol County House of Correction, minus 254 days for time served, meaning 111 more days. The judge suspended the other 1½ years in jail pending completion of 2 years’ probation. Da Silva was released April 16, after 80 days in jail. 

The sheriff’s office declined to comment on Da Silva’s release date, saying it cannot release an individual’s specific sentencing information under state law. Generally, Assistant General Counsel Edward Meyers said, an inmate’s sentence can be reduced by credit for time already served and by “good time” (credit earned in state-approved education and work programs). 

The Light asked Meyers if ICE had ever asked the sheriff’s office about Da Silva; he did not respond.

Da Silva was out on probation when ICE detained him. According to court records, he missed a probation hearing while in ICE custody on Sept. 25, resulting in a criminal arrest warrant.

The ICE press release also cited charges against Da Silva of assault with a dangerous weapon and assault on a family household member. Those charges were dismissed in 2023.

The Light previously reported that another man ICE named, João Manuel Matos Ferreira, 50, was charged in Fall River District Court with two counts of indecent assault and battery on a child under 14 and two indecent exposure charges. Records show the case was continued without a finding, then closed — a disposition that generally results from completion of probation. In January 2019, Customs and Border Protection stopped Ferreira at Logan Airport in Boston and gave him a notice to appear for removal proceedings, according to a court filing; the government sought to remove him from the U.S. for having committed a crime involving “moral turpitude.”

In 2009, Ferreira was found guilty of two counts of assault with a dangerous weapon and was sentenced to probation, Fall River District Court records show.

Another of the seven men, Ronan Rodrigues dos Santos, of Brazil, faces felony charges of assault with a dangerous weapon and carrying a dangerous weapon and five misdemeanor charges, including threat to commit a crime, disorderly conduct, and disturbing the peace. They stem from an incident in Fall River June 6 where he allegedly threatened to kill a man who owed him money. A temporary restraining order associated with that case filed June 6 expired two days later, when neither party participated in a hearing. Dos Santos had a hearing scheduled for Sept. 23, which was rescheduled on court order after the ICE arrest.

Ricardo Faustin, 36, of Haiti, faced seven felony charges in Fall River, all dismissed. The charges stemmed from an alleged voodoo extortion scheme in October 2025: five of larceny over $1,200 by false pretense, another of larceny over $1,200 by single scheme, and one of conspiracy. He faced six more misdemeanor charges related to the same incident, including: five of threat to commit a crime and another of larceny under $1,200 by false pretense.

However, all charges against Faustin were dismissed on June 26. In a memorandum of law submitted by his attorney, Scott F. Gleason, supporting the motion to dismiss, he called the police investigation “flawed, inadequate, and incomplete,” and said it failed to show probable cause to charge him with a crime. In the police reports, Faustin’s name appeared once, which Gleason argued was not enough to connect him to the other defendants’ alleged scheme. Faustin served 12 days in the Bristol County Jail in October 2025, until a judge granted his bail petition.

Light staff found no judicial records in either Massachusetts or Rhode Island for two of the men named in the release, Raphael De Oliveira Batista, of Brazil, and Cristopher Paul Augui Cajas, of Ecuador. (This could be because they were arrested in another state.) Asked for further information on the charges, ICE directed The Light to file a Freedom of Information Act request. ICE denied those requests.

A misdemeanor drunk-driving charge

DaSilva Hughes said that when charges against detained immigrants are serious felonies, immigration advocates support their deportation. But that is often not the case, such as with the seventh man on the ICE list, Marlon Alexis Portillo-Garcia, 40, a Honduran national.

ICE said in the news release that Portillo-Garcia had a conviction for driving under the influence. A review of Rhode Island Judiciary records by The Light found a misdemeanor charge of driving under the influence with a blood alcohol level of .15 or greater, stemming from an incident in North Kingstown on Oct. 16, 2025. According to court records, he pleaded no contest to the charge on Feb. 13 at Kent County District Court. The judge ordered him to perform 10 hours of community service, attend substance abuse counseling, and pay fines and fees of up to $783.75. Authorities also suspended his license for three months. After the ICE arrest, Portillo-Garcia filed a habeas corpus petition in federal court and is now out on bond.

“They make it seem like it’s something so severe, but it’s a misdemeanor,” DaSilva Hughes said. “This administration is all about the hype and sensationalism.”

The other 75 arrestees

DaSilva Hughes added that she thinks that’s why the other 75 detainees were not mentioned.

The week after the raids, The Light reviewed Massachusetts court records for 23 of the 82 men and found that 19 had no criminal charges on their records, excluding misdemeanors related to entering the country without inspection or overstaying visas. Of the remaining four, only one, Ferreira, had a felony charge.

That tracks with data compiled and analyzed by Transactional Record Access Clearinghouse Immigration, a non-partisan data analysis think tank, which found that almost 71% of ICE detainees as of July 2026 did not have any criminal convictions.

“They don’t want to bring that out because it doesn’t satisfy their narrative,” DaSilva Hughes said, “so that backfires.”

At least 33 of the 82 South Coast men arrested by ICE challenged their detention in federal court with the help of volunteer attorneys, The Light reported in September. 

Several were freed on bond this fall, The Light’s latest review of cases found. In three men’s cases, the judges who granted them bond noted that they had no criminal record in the U.S.

“The respondent has no criminal history,” an immigration judge wrote when ordering the release of a Guatemalan fish house worker from Cranston, Rhode Island, on Oct. 27, “and as such, there is no evidence that he poses a danger to the community.”

Email Kevin G. Andrade at kandrade@newbedfordlight.org. Email Eleonora Bianchi at ebianchi@newbedfordlight.org.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *