|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
Since July, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement has been sending administrative subpoenas to the Bristol County Sheriff’s Office seeking jail booking records, a records request filed by The Light has revealed.
ICE also asked for information about specific detainees five times in mid-September, records show.
The sheriff’s office has not answered the subpoenas, which are not signed by a judge.
Fourteen subpoenas sought booking intake lists covering dates from July 15 through Oct. 21. They demanded the full legal names and dates of birth of everyone newly booked in during the specified periods and instructed jail staff to send the information directly to ICE.
Bristol County Sheriff Paul Heroux said his office didn’t provide the information on the intake lists, since the subpoenas lacked names identifying whom ICE was seeking.
“You have to actually have a specific target in mind, You can’t just say, ‘Give me a John Doe subpoena,’” said Heroux. “We don’t have to honor those John Doe subpoenas. We’re not giving them anything.”
Federal immigration officials, not judges, signed the subpoenas. They read, “Failure to comply with this subpoena may subject you to an order of contempt by a federal District Court, as provided by 8 U.S.C. § 1225(d)(4)(B).”
Administrative subpoenas are not self-enforcing like a judicial warrant is, but they can be enforced through courts. If a recipient refuses to comply, ICE can seek a federal court order. Until then, ICE cannot force compliance.
“They must think we’re stupid,” said Heroux, “or they think that we don’t have multiple attorneys looking at this.”
Multiple attorneys, in fact, are looking into it. Heroux said each sheriff’s office is working with the Massachusetts Sheriffs’ Association’s legal counsel and the state attorney general’s office to assess whether or not sheriffs are required to respond to these administrative subpoenas.
“As of right now,” Heroux said, “the consensus is that we don’t need to.”
Carrie Hill, executive director of the Massachusetts Sheriffs’ Association and an attorney, confirmed to The Light that other sheriffs’ offices have been receiving subpoenas from ICE and that both her office and the Massachusetts Attorney General’s Office are aware of the situation. She declined to provide further details, citing attorney-client privilege.
The attorney general’s office did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
The requests began two months before ICE detained 82 men in southeastern Massachusetts the week of Sept. 21.
It is unclear whether the subpoenas were intended to prepare for the September arrests, but the request signals a shift in how ICE tries to obtain information.
Heroux said that ICE could use the state police fingerprint system to find information on jailed inmates instead of insisting on getting information from sheriffs.
He said he suspects this might be a tactic to create a record of his office’s refusal to cooperate. “So that way they can use that against us later.”
Courts have enforced ICE subpoenas in other states
ICE has already taken sheriffs to federal court elsewhere in the country for refusing to comply with administrative subpoenas.
In Oregon, ICE issued 10 subpoenas to four counties in July 2025, seeking personal information and booking records for individuals under post-prison supervision. Three counties refused, citing the state’s sanctuary law, while a fourth sought legal clarification. Oregon’s U.S. attorney filed a court petition, and in November 2025, U.S. District Judge Michael McShane ordered compliance with the nine remaining subpoenas, ruling that they were enforceable under federal law.
The U.S. attorney filed a second court petition to enforce new subpoenas against the same counties in April 2026. In June, McShane again ordered compliance, and the counties turned over the documents.
In Louisiana, ICE issued about 20 subpoenas to the Orleans Parish Sheriff’s Office between October 2025 and January 2026, seeking inmate records, immigration status information and interviews with detainees. After the sheriff’s office refused to comply, ICE sought court enforcement. In May, U.S. Magistrate Judge Eva Dossier ordered ICE to revise the subpoenas and later recommended that the U.S. District Court enforce the revised versions.
Heroux limited cooperation
Since November 2025, Heroux has restricted the information his office shares with federal immigration agencies, The Light previously reported.
Before that, the sheriff’s office routinely shared court dates, booking information and upcoming bail or release times with ICE, sometimes facilitating immigration arrests on the South Coast.
Then, Heroux began requiring federal immigration officers to file public records requests if they want information on court hearings, bookings and upcoming bail or release times.
Heroux sharply criticized ICE after immigration agents killed two U.S. citizens in Minneapolis in January. He also said he had begun to fear that cooperation with immigration enforcement could expose his office to further legal liability, after his office’s 2025 settlement over a 2020 confrontation with immigration detainees at the Dartmouth jail under then-Sheriff Thomas Hodgson.
September subpoenas on 5 men
ICE also issued subpoenas between Sept. 16 and 28 concerning five specific individuals in custody. Each was accompanied by an administrative arrest warrant (authorizing federal agents to arrest the inmates) and an immigration detainer.
The subpoenas directed Heroux to serve the documents on the detainees and ordered them to appear at the ICE office in Burlington on a designated date. Heroux said he gives inmates a copy of any detainer so they are aware of it, but does not provide the full subpoena documents because of the Protect Act.
“In that case, all we’re doing is delivering a message to the detainee that says, ‘Hey, ICE wants to get custody of you,’” said Heroux. “That is something we are required to do. But we’re not giving ICE any information. We’re just being kind of a delivery person.”
The detainers asked the sheriff’s office to hold the inmates for up to 48 hours beyond when they would otherwise be released, giving ICE time to take custody.
Heroux said his office could not legally extend detention, because the 2017 Lunn v. Commonwealth decision prohibits state officers from holding someone solely on a civil immigration detainer.
“They’re still asking us to break state law,” he said.
The Light reached out to ICE with questions about the subpoenas sent to the sheriff’s office, but the agency declined to provide any details.
“For operational security purposes, ICE does not disclose information pertaining to current or ongoing operations, including law enforcement plans, tactics or strategies,” a spokesperson wrote.
Email Eleonora Bianchi at ebianchi@newbedfordlight.org.



What a difference a new sheriff makes! Thank you Sheriff Paul Heroux.