|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
NEW BEDFORD — When Superintendent Andrew O’Leary sat before the New Bedford School Committee on Nov. 11, he banged the same drum that he had been beating for months, just more forte this time.
New Bedford Public Schools, he said, could be facing a massive funding gap of over $15 million because of an enrollment drop of 329 students, or 2.6%. Multiple demographic factors contributed, he said, above all a decline in immigration, leading to 300 fewer English language learners, widely seen as a proxy for immigrant students.
“It’s very clear from the enrollment numbers we submitted in October we are facing a significant structural or systemic challenge as we build our plans,” O’Leary said.
The data points to one clear cause, local officials say: aggressive operations by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement. And now school finances are on the line.
“The decline in school enrollment is hardly unique to New Bedford, but it has been exacerbated here by the harmful effects of ICE’s overly aggressive tactics, which have discouraged immigration to the city,” Mayor Jon Mitchell told The Light in an email. “Because the level of state education support is pegged to enrollment, and because healthcare and other costs are steadily rising, the District’s finances are already feeling the pinch.”
Other mid-sized Gateway Cities saw large declines as well. In Fall River and Brockton, enrollment dropped by almost 3% and over 2% respectively. Springfield saw a drop of around 800 students. The numbers contributed to a 14,684 enrollment decline statewide, 46% of those English Language Learners, according to a report from the Massachusetts Budget and Policy Center.
Now New Bedford Public Schools and other districts are planning for a fiscal crunch.
“This is unprecedented for us in New Bedford,” O’Leary later told the Committee. “Certainly it’s not unprecedented in Massachusetts in the past two years. [And] perhaps in large part across the state, it’s going to be a new reality.”
Chapter 70’s state aid
In 2019, then-Gov. Charlie Baker, a Republican, signed the Student Opportunity Act into law. It overhauled the state education aid formula, known as Chapter 70. Its main goal at the time was equity in outcomes.
“By and large, Gateway Cities were the biggest beneficiaries of this Opportunity Act, and rightfully so,” said Rep. António F.D. Cabral, whose district includes the South End. “That’s been really transformative to some of our Gateway City schools.”
The law starts with a foundational budget that takes into account administration, education costs, building expenses, and more. State aid guarantees a minimum of $160 per student annually. Beyond that, the primary factor determining state aid is enrollment. Factors such as special needs, English language learners, and low-income students increase that aid amount. That money is then given to the municipality to distribute to the public school system, charter schools, and other schools.
That budget is calculated based on enrollment on Oct. 1. According to data from the Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education, there were 14,160 pupils in New Bedford schools (including charter schools) for the fiscal 2025-2026 school year — amounting to about $22,210 per pupil. Chapter 70 aid accounted for $19,155 of per pupil spending.
State data showed that New Bedford schools received more than $271 million in state aid for the 2026-2027 school year. Over $38 million of that went to charter schools and others through school choice programs.
That means New Bedford Public Schools received more than $233 million for this school year based on the 12,449 students enrolled on Oct. 1, 2025.
In New Bedford, just two weeks before the Oct. 1, 2026 cutoff, ICE detained 82 immigrants on the South Coast, according to the agency. Estimates from Gov. Maura Healey’s office put the number detained in New Bedford at around 40.
Those arrests appeared to make a dent in the schools as well. At the Oct. 5 school committee meeting, before officials finalized the Oct. 1 numbers, O’Leary accounted for a $10 million gap in funding following a decline of about 200 students.
“Not only is enrollment down, we’re also seeing it decline as rosters are cleared,” O’Leary warned at that meeting. “The impact of the events of two weeks ago certainly will have an impact.”
O’Leary reported that the Oct. 1 enrollment this year was 12,120 students at the Nov. 11 meeting.
“Now we have to budget for a 12,000-student district,” O’Leary said. “And that’s hitting the brakes hard.”
Disagreement and consequences
Not everyone is convinced that immigration enforcement caused the drop in enrollment. Among those was Christopher Cotter, a school committee member and New Bedford police officer.
“As far as Mr. O’Leary’s comments in the immigration attendance decline, I find this a guess on his part,” Cotter told The Light in an email. “According to the NBPS policy, we do not track any student with an immigration status. How can his statement be true then?
“Immigration status is not tracked, NOR ASKED, of our students. Parents need to send their kids to school if that is what our tax money is paying for,” continued Cotter, who has come under fire due to social media posts before the September raids in support of ICE.
Nonetheless, O’Leary said the district is starting to plan for the shortfall. He said he saw few options to cut down further on administrative spending and that he was exploring consolidations in transportation.
“We are going to start on non-school-based reductions,” he said. “It won’t be dramatic.”
He emphasized that a smaller student body would not necessarily mean a reduction in spending.
O’Leary focused on employee health insurance costs, which grew 8% between fiscal 2026 and 2027, and retiree pensions as examples of what could be affected.
School Committee Member Richard Porter said in an email the impending fiscal crisis needed to be taken seriously. “I applaud the superintendent’s commitment to responsible budgeting,” he wrote.
“Fewer students don’t necessarily mean lower costs,” Porter added. “We must prioritize student achievement, support families, and secure the resources our district needs.”
Cotter, the only school committee member to vote down a resolution to officialize a school policy around ICE activities in line with the PROTECT Act, expressed skepticism at the idea of a fiscal gap. He placed the onus for it squarely on Beacon Hill.
“When we have a Governor who doesn’t treat education as a priority, then the education system will start to fail,” he said. “This [is] not a local issue, this is a state issue.”
No other school committee members responded to requests for comment from The Light.
Legislative efforts
O’Leary said he hoped for the state to step in to some extent.
“I would expect that there would be some legislative relief,” he said. “I would not expect that that would extend to the extent of the deficit we’re facing.”
Under Chapter 70, the state is required to form a foundation budget review commission to explore any necessary reforms. That commission was convened as part of the fiscal 2027 budget.
“The Healey-Driscoll Administration is closely monitoring enrollment trends and working with school districts to ensure stability and high-quality education for all students,” a spokesperson for the Executive Office for Education told The Light in an email. The spokesperson directed attention to the addition of $4 million in education aid to the fiscal 2027 budget to offset reductions in English language learners.
“Recognizing the impact of the Trump Administration’s immigration policies, she also signed the PROTECT Act to keep ICE out of schools,” the spokesperson continued.
Members of the city’s Beacon Hill delegation who spoke with The Light said the enrollment decline was stupefying.
“[That] is a lot,” State Rep. Christopher Hendricks, who represents the North End of the city, said in an interview before the Nov. 11 meeting. “It being tied to immigration, I completely see that.
“I can’t imagine [the drop] is not tied to the way ICE has been acting in the city,” he added. “It looks like we’ll certainly have to make that one of our top priorities going into the next session.”
Cabral said he had not heard much among his colleagues in the Legislature about moves to mitigate the impact of immigration enforcement on enrollment and school aid.
“That’s not part of the conversation right now,” he said. “But perhaps it should be part of the conversation.”
Mitchell, O’Leary, and Hendricks confirmed that a meeting with New Bedford’s incoming Beacon Hill delegation is in the works for before Dec. 14, the final school committee meeting of the year. Officials want to explore options for relief through the Legislature, perhaps in conjunction with other impacted districts.
“In 2019, we worked hard to build a statewide coalition to advocate for more education funding for Massachusetts cities, and a similar effect may again be necessary,” Mitchell said.
Contact Kevin G. Andrade at kandrade@newbedfordlight.org.


