|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
Fairhaven Town Meeting members voted 92-77 Tuesday night to ban the future use of automated license plate readers, approving a citizen petition that would prevent the renewal of existing contracts and eventually require the removal of six Flock Safety cameras used by the Fairhaven Police Department.
But the ban will not take effect immediately. The proposed bylaw must first undergo review by the Massachusetts Attorney General’s Office, which will determine whether it complies with state law and the Massachusetts Constitution.
If approved, the bylaw would prohibit the town from purchasing, installing or operating automated license plate reader systems and renewing existing contracts. Fairhaven’s current agreements with Flock Safety expire in September 2028, according to police Chief Daniel Dorgan. The proposal would require the cameras to be removed within 30 days of contract expiration.
Town Counsel Heather White raised questions about whether Fairhaven has the legal authority to prohibit police from using equipment already acquired by the department.
She said the Strong Police Chief statute gives police chiefs authority over departmental property. She said there is a strong legal argument that the statute would allow Dorgan to continue using the existing cameras even if the Town Meeting approved the prohibition.
However, White said no court or state authority has definitively ruled on whether a town can adopt such a ban.
State Rep. Mark Sylvia, who also serves as Fairhaven’s elected town moderator, said that the attorney general could approve the bylaw, reject it for violating state law or determine that certain provisions are enforceable while others are not.
“This vote is setting precedent,” Sylvia said. “We will be the first town that will have adopted a bylaw that would in effect ban or prohibit the use of ALPRs in the future.”
The Attorney General’s Office generally has 90 days to review proposed town bylaws after they are submitted.
Debate
Joseph Russell, who submitted the citizen petition, opened the debate by arguing that residents, not police alone, should decide whether Fairhaven continues using the technology.
“A town meeting is not a rubber stamp. It is self-government. Neighbors in the open voting on what our town will do in our name,” Russell said.
Russell argued that the cameras record every passing vehicle, whether or not anyone inside is suspected of a crime. He cast doubt on police audits as a safeguard, noting that officers themselves decide what reasons to enter for their searches.
He pointed to The Light’s investigation, which found that a Fairhaven officer had described more than 750 searches as “welfare checks” when they were actually part of narcotics investigations.
“The chief confirmed to the newspaper themselves that they were narcotics investigations labeled false on purpose,” Russell said. “A log only protects anyone if what gets typed into it is true.”
Dorgan made the case for keeping the cameras, pointing to investigations in which they helped identify suspects in an illegal firearm case and a fatal road-rage incident. In another case, he said, a camera captured a truck carrying 55-gallon drums along Sconticut Neck Road, then recorded it passing again without them, helping police identify a suspect.
“The camera reading the plate is a lead. It’s not proof,” Dorgan said.
Using screenshots of the Flock system, Dorgan showed Town Meeting members how officers search for vehicles by license plate or appearance. He stressed that the cameras cannot identify drivers and that a match alone is not enough to make an arrest. Records are deleted after seven days unless needed for an investigation, he said. He said at the moment about half of his 38 sworn-in officers are trained on the use of Flock.
Dorgan also addressed The Light’s investigation, confirming that an officer conducted more than 750 searches labeled as welfare checks during narcotics investigations.
He called the reporting “a little misleading,” saying the searches involved multiple vehicles over several months. Fairhaven police withheld license plate numbers from the records provided to The Light, and The Light never reported only one vehicle was involved.
Public debate and vote
The debate revealed divisions among Town Meeting members over how much surveillance residents should accept in exchange for a tool that police say helps solve crimes.
James Anderson of Precinct 1 took the microphone to warn that advances in artificial intelligence could make Flock’s data vulnerable, no matter what safeguards police put in place.
Cameron Durant of Precinct 5 raised a different concern: whether Town Meeting had the authority to impose restrictions on equipment managed by the police chief.
“I believe Article 9 raises a serious legal question, not simply about the license plate readers, but about the division of authority within our town government,” Durant said.
Kevin Grant of Precinct 1 acknowledged that the cameras help police catch criminals but argued that the potential for abuse outweighed their benefits. He pointed to The Light’s investigation, which found that more than 3,000 law enforcement agencies across 44 states searched Fairhaven’s Flock network in a single month.
“Our rules mean nothing to agencies in other states,” Grant said. “As we don’t let police search property without probable cause and a warrant, we shouldn’t let them track anyone’s movements without one either.”
A show of hands initially led the moderator to declare the article defeated. But seven members objected, leading to a counted vote instead. The moderator explained once more what a yes or no vote meant, and members stood from their seats as tellers counted them.
Ultimately the count showed a majority of members sided with the ban, voting 92-77. The proposed bylaw now goes to the Massachusetts attorney general for review.
Asked for comment after the vote, Chief Dorgan said, “We’ll see what the attorney general will do.”
Email Eleonora Bianchi at ebianchi@newbedfordlight.org.


