Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

As a Dartmouth resident and independent, I am interested in a fundamental question about our democracy: Should every voter have the same opportunity to participate in choosing the candidates who advance to the general election, regardless of political affiliation?

Approximately 67% of Massachusetts voters are independent, often called unenrolled, meaning they are not registered with a political party. Under the current primary system, independent voters may choose a Democratic or Republican ballot in a state primary. However, voters who prefer not to affiliate with either major party may feel that the current system does not reflect their political independence and the fact they chose not to join a party.

Question 3 on Nov. 3 calls for changing to an election system where there would be one primary ballot where all candidates, regardless of political affiliation, would appear, and voters vote for any candidate. The two highest primary vote-getters would face off in the general election. Municipal elections in Massachusetts cities for mayor and local offices use this system. Question 3 would change the way our statewide elections are conducted and be run in the same way.

The Democratic and Republican party leadership oppose Question 3. There has been a lot of false information circulating about Question 3. First, that it will favor wealthy, self-funded candidates. This is not true. In California, for example, which has the all-party primary (or open primary), Tom Steyer spent $200 million on his primary gubernatorial candidacy this year while the two advancing candidates, a Democrat and Republican, each spent under $20 million. 

Moreover, the U.S. Supreme Court decided on June 30, 2026 that for federal elections the political parties can spend unlimited amounts of money on their candidates. In National Republican Senatorial Committee (NRSC) v. Federal Election Commission (FEC), the Supreme Court ruled 6–3 that limits on “coordinated party expenditures” violate the First Amendment.

With all-party primaries, third parties, independent and lesser-known candidates will be able to participate on a level playing field with the major parties. Their names, with party affiliation if they choose, would appear side by side with the major party candidates. More competition, in other words.

Massachusetts has the least competitive elections of all states in the U.S. according to Ballotpedia, the nation’s premier resource for unbiased information on elections, politics, and policy, which means that in most cases whoever wins the primary automatically wins the general election. In most Massachusetts races, candidates in the general election face no opposition. 

The Massachusetts State Legislature is among the least productive legislatures in the country. Competition is required for debate, dialogue, and winning over the broadest cross section of voters who want candidates to discuss solutions and engage voters on issues and develop and enact policy. The general election following an all-party primary will be a meaningful contest with two competitive candidates.

The Democratic and Republican parties seek to control an increasingly narrow cohort of voters and election outcomes. This puts the politicians in charge. The all-party primary puts the people in charge by instituting one ballot with all candidates listed and voters choose who they want to vote for from the entire field. Increased competition incentivizes candidates to appeal to the broadest constituency across party lines.

Massachusetts voters have an opportunity to consider strengthening our democracy on Nov. 3. 

Douglas A. Balder is a resident of Dartmouth.


6 replies on “Opinion: Will the ‘all-party primary’ make Mass. elections more democratic?”

  1. If you have 10D and 2R running in a combined (jungle) primary, you run a very real risk of having the 2 R on the general election ballot despite the fact that they get a combined 30% of the vote.
    1v1 they may not beat a single Democrat but they can win a combined primary because many candidates dilute the vote. This is the fatal flaw that makes jungle primaries an absolutely terrible idea.

    The correct way to give everyone a chance in the general election is Ranked Choice. Then nobody “wastes” their vote on a candidate that has no chance.

    1. Who are you to try to tell voters that they don’t have a chance to elected? Individuals like you should rethink what Democracy is all about. And the correct way to give people a chance in a general election isn’t ranked choice, it’s that candidate’s ability to get his message out. Ranked Choice is only monkeying around with the electoral process that has worked for over 240 years..

  2. “Jungle Primaries” are for the primates amongst us and not for the voting public.

  3. Jungle Primaries, Oligarks, two Republicans!!!! Must be Halloween.

    Always thought these scare tactics were beneath my Democratic friends.
    Sounds more like MAGA than Mass.

    One Ballot, every candidate, vote for whoever you want. That sounds good to me.

  4. I to a large degree agree with Mr. Balder. I wrote an opinion regarding Ballot Question 3 on an earlier article. Here it is:

    It is interesting to read the various objections to the “non-party” primary. The common theme of the objectors, to me, is to protect the powerful vested interests imbedded in the current party system. I find it really rich to argue that monied interests would have more influence in a “non-party” primary. Who is so foolish to believe that big money is not a dominant player in the current two-party system. (Watch the lobbyists carrying their bags of money to the state house and seated at the best Boston restaurants with the traditional party players).

    The most powerful reason that I support a “non-party” primary and a “yes” vote on the ballot question 3 is the current radical, hateful and extreme division between the two existing dominant parties and their official platforms. It is well understood that the winners today are usually more extreme to either the left or right if they want to win the primary. It is very hard, if not impossible, for a “down the middle” political advocate to become nominated by either party. I am one of the 67% super majority of registered MA voters who are “unaffiliated” (also described as “independent”). I am a moderate in my political views and do not want to be limited in my vote in the general election to the product of either the Republican or Democrat political party regimes.

    As an improvement to Question 3, I also agree with the writer of this opinion piece that Rank Choice would be a better option, but that was not on the ballot question as a possibility. I chose the better way for me, i.e. non-party primary.

Comments are closed.