Firefighters fight a blaze that burned down the defunct Hawthorne Country Club on May 7, 2023. Photo provided by Dartmouth Fire District 2.
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

FALL RIVER — Shawn Medeiros pleaded guilty to setting the Hawthorne Country Club on fire and was sentenced to 10 years of probation in Bristol County Superior Court on Friday.

The clubhouse at 970 Tucker Road in Dartmouth had been vacant for years when the fire caused severe damage in May 2023. Investigators ruled it an arson soon after and later charged Medeiros with a felony for burning the building.

But it’s not clear whether Medeiros acted entirely alone. 

“It certainly seems that somebody influenced you to engage in this behavior, though I have no evidence of that,” Judge Raffi Yessayan told Medeiros in court on Friday.

The judge said prosecutors had also indicated that they believed Medeiros was “influenced” to set the fire, but he didn’t go into detail. The DA’s office declined to address the judge’s comment in response to The Light. 

The country club is owned by the family of Carlos “The Codfather” Rafael, the former fishing mogul who has transitioned into real estate ventures since his conviction for tax evasion and fish mislabeling forced him out of the fishing industry. The family has been working to develop the site into housing since before the fire.

Medeiros initially claimed he was innocent, and Rafael backed him. 

Shawn Lee Medeiros, the suspect in the Hawthorne Country Club arson fire, sits outside the courtroom of the Fall River District Court before his pretrial conference on June 10, 2024. Credit: Eleonora Bianchi / The New Bedford Light

The arson charge carries up to 10 years in prison. Prosecutors had recommended a sentence of two and a half to six years, while Medeiros’s defense lawyer Melissa Hendrie bargained for only probation.

Judge Yessayan said it was fortunate no one was hurt in the fire. 

“If a single firefighter had been hurt, this would be a very different story as to what you’re receiving.”

He told Medeiros he was sticking to Hendrie’s recommendation “based on things about your mental capacities and things like that.” He added that Medeiros’s lack of a criminal record before the arson also shaped his thinking.

Hendrie described Medeiros, 34, as “naive” and “trusting.” He works hard as a mechanic, she said, living a “relatively simple life” with his mother and father in New Bedford.

In court, Medeiros answered the judge’s questions quietly and respectfully. He said he took “full responsibility” for burning the clubhouse. He and his mother declined to comment when approached by a Light reporter before and after the hearing.

The probation sentence also includes requirements that Medeiros be screened for mental health and addiction issues, and forfeit any firearms he may own.

After the hearing, Hendrie told The Light that she and her client were happy with the case’s outcome.

“I think he’s just happy to move on,” she said.

Assistant District Attorney Jason Mohan, the prosecutor assigned to the case, told the judge that the arson investigation found a fire accelerant had been used in three parts of the clubhouse building.

Medeiros was on the property to help move furniture to another building for an event. The Rafael family has said they don’t know Medeiros and that he was brought along by another person they usually hire.

Medeiros was captured disabling a game camera on the property and gave “conflicting” answers to investigators, Mohan said. 

Mohan declined to answer a Light reporter’s questions after the hearing and referred them to the DA spokesperson.

The spokesperson, Jennifer Sowa, said in an email that the DA’s office has not found probable cause to charge anyone else in connection with the arson. Asked about the judge’s reference to Medeiros being “influenced,” Sowa wrote that she “cannot comment on the statement of the judge or what he… meant in his statement.”

Sowa did not immediately respond to The Light’s follow-up email on Friday afternoon asking a second time whether the investigation was still open.

Rafael family feels vindicated

For Jeff Hathaway, Rafael’s son-in-law, who manages the family’s real estate projects, Medeiros’s guilty plea was a bit of an I-told-you-so moment.

“Everybody thought we set the fire,” Hathaway said in a phone interview after Friday’s hearing. “Long story short, I’m glad he pled guilty.”

The legal owner of the Hawthorne Country Club is Bliss Investors LLC, a company that Mohan said Friday was owned by Rafael and two of his daughters. Hathaway disputed that characterization, saying “the LLC is owned by the family, not Carlos [Rafael],” but didn’t outright say that the prosecutor’s statement was false when pressed by a Light reporter.

The Light tried to reach Rafael on Friday, but his phone number was no longer active. Hathaway said Rafael was out of the country.

The property was initially slated to be sold to luxury homebuilder Toll Brothers at the time of the fire, but it’s now under agreement for sale to a new group of buyers, including the Town of Dartmouth, Buzzards Bay Coalition, and a local homebuilder, Hathaway said. The proposal includes housing and conservation land.

Hathaway acknowledged that the circumstances appeared suspicious, with the family owning an insured property that it planned to sell for redevelopment. They have received a nearly $800,000 payout from the insurance policy, he said.

But Hathaway insisted that the insurance company required the family to take out the policy, one they didn’t even want since the property was dilapidated and would soon be demolished. And he emphasized that opposition to the project from Dartmouth residents has forced them back to the drawing board repeatedly, which he said was expensive.

The family has no relationship with Medeiros, who was brought to the property without their knowledge as the “guest” of another person who the family typically hires for chores, Hathaway said.

“‘Influenced’ is weird,” he said, referencing the judge’s word choice to describe Medeiros’s motives. “Because we don’t even know the guy.”

Email Grace Ferguson at gferguson@newbedfordlight.org



Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *